Good Fences

By mandevu at 9:55 am on Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Yesterday, I took a little ride up the main road to Siem Reap to see what I could see. We have had a couple of major rainstorms, which should have started to soften the soil enough for farmers to start plowing the fields which they will be planting to rain-fed rice. About 17km or so north of town, there is a large lake which spans both sides of the road. There is not a lot right around the lake, along the road there is a little place to buy snacks and lounge in a hammock lakeside.

However, I was interested in the farm across the road from the snack dealers.

0_farm_overall1.jpg

They have a diverse little homegarden set up: coconuts, toddy palms, bananas, bamboo, cassava, and a bunch of other trees which I did not recognize. However, they also had a small irrigated plot of mung beans which you can see over on the far right of the image (it is tough to see, but look for the tree branches used for trellises).

Also grazing freely in this area along the lakeshore, near the farm, was a small herd of cows. I do not know who the owners were. I often see cows wandering freely, though herds grazing far from home will be tended by young boys. In this case, I think that they might have benefited from allocating someone to watch the cows. Clearly the forage around the lake is not in very good condition. However, mung beans are rich in nitrogen and likey pretty tasty (with forages, there is an inverse relationship between carbon and nitrogen content, which is mirrored in palatability– woody stuff does not taste as good, and has less protein). The cows are onto this.

1_bright_idea.jpg

There is a light fence protecting the bean plot, though I think that it was just constructed of bamboo and debris, and am certain that it was not particularly robust.

2_first_breach.jpg

Breach it and they will come…

3_follow_the_leader.jpg

From another angle, you can see the end result. I did not stick around to see if the others joined their fellows in the bean plot. Note also the irrigation pump.

4_success.jpg

The farmers were no where to be seen. But I feel for them. Having hurled both stones and curses at cows and lazy herdboys in my maize/pigeon pea intercropping demonstration plots back in Tanzania, I can sympathize (believe me, more civil attempts at negotiation were totally ineffective). I am a strong advocate of live fencing, nice, dense thorny stuff. I have seen people use Pandanus to that effect here, but I do not yet know how well it would do when the floods are up. However, I think that there is a common farmstead rattan which would work on flooding areas. Though I have seen that managed more as clumps or thick hedgerows. I expect that I will have a better grip on the fencing situation, once I am out talking to farmers more often.

Fences and hedgerows are not just for keeping things in or out. They are pretty important ecologically too, potentially representing a substantial fraction of a landscape’s agrodiversity and contributing significantly to landscape heterogeneity. They are places to grow or manage useful plants (be they for medicines, food, fodder, mulch, firewood and more). Moreover, they can be crucial habitat for anything from beneficial predatory insects (as in, the kind that eats agricultural pests) to birds, herps and more.

Mind you, these are just my musings on fencing. I am not here to tell anyone what to do. My goal is a better understanding of what they are doing, how it is changing and why.

Filed under: Agriculture, Agrodiversity, Anecdotes, Cambodia, Ecology, Images, Map

3 Comments »

1
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Maytel

10 April 2007 @ 6:36 pm

I’m pretty sure that Development Alternatives in Stung Treng have been working on some live fencing solutions

From my notes: funded by US Department of Agriculture “Food for Progress”
Legumes shrubs for livestock a project component.
20,000 planted in Kratie used the shrubs to replace fences with living hedges, leaves feed to livestock, plant survival 75%, zeucaenia variety purchased seed from battambang

The dried leaf 800 R/kg sold and can also be used for firewood and charcoal

Stylosanthes broadcast along the road side in Thailand for livestock feed, seed bought from Thailand

2
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by mandevu

11 April 2007 @ 7:44 am

Very interesting. As something of a live fence fan, I will indeed be reporting more on what sorts of fencing I am seeing, along with where the ideas, technologies and seeds came from, and why it does or does not matter…

And, I did not know that the USDA still funded any overseas projects! Likewise, very interesting!

3
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Pingback by mandevu.net » Fences revisited

31 May 2007 @ 7:34 am

[…] I have noted before, I am a fan of fences. In agricultural landscapes, they have the obvious use of dividing land. […]

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment